Thursday, March 11, 2010

Season 15 Draft Recap - Hartford through Los Angeles

Cal Nicholson
Hartford
Whalers
Age: 18B/T: L/L
Born: Santa Cruz, CA
Position(s): P (ClA)
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Hartford Whalers
--With the #8 pick overall, Hartford expected to get a stud player of epic proportions, and they nearly did in C Mitch Titan.  But ultimately Titan's salary demands were bigger than Cronos' appetite, and he refused to sign with the Whalers.  But you can't fault Hartford for swinging for the fences in a very poor draft, and as a reward they are guaranteed the #8 pick next season in what will hopefully be a more fertile draft pool.  What they ended up with as a consolation was supplemental pick RP Cal Nicholson, who is very similar in quality to Cleveland's #1 overall pick, but with slightly better splits and much better velocity.   Nicholson has the potential to be a very good ML RP vs. lefties.  Supplemental pick SP Jose Estrada has ML long relief potential, but isn't the type of player one usually expects at #34 overall.  2nd round pick SS Les Spivey, cousin of Dover #1 pick SS Howard Spivey, is only slightly less talented than his higher round counterpart.  One could actually put them on a comparison chart and see them come out nearly the same, so this has to be considered a great value pick for Hartford, and an indictment on Dover that the essentially the same player could have been had 62 picks later.  The rest of Hartford's draft is pretty average, but all told this was one of the more successful drafts in the sense they guaranteed themselves a high pick next year and still made out with two potential ML players.
Grade: B+

Kent Milton
Iowa City
Corn Dogs
Age: 20B/T: S/R
Born: Sturgis, MI
Position(s): SS
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Iowa City Corn Dogs
--Usually the #16 pick will get you somebody really great, but not this year.  What Iowa City ended up with was a very serviceable player in SS Kent Milton, but not the potential all star they were probably hoping to get.  Milton does have a very nice glove, and his hitting skills should net him a place in the line up, especially in the National League.  But he's not a great hitter by any stretch, and will need to develop his glove for a while in the minors before he's ready to go in the majors.  Milton reminds the Cobb Times Herald quite a bit of current ML SS Mickey Corino, who has some gold gloves to his name.  2nd round pick RF Trey Ventrella has great splits and batting eye, but his contact and power are abysmal, and more suited to the SS or CF position, which means he will probably spend most of his career in the minors as his glove just isn't good enough to move to another position, and corner OF spots are usually reserved for better hitters. After Ventrella the Iowa City draft got some good minor leaguers, but nothing else of real note.
Grade: C+

Shane Lindblom
Jackson
Pollocks
Age: 18B/T: L/L
Born: Belmont, NC
Position(s): P (SP3)
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Jackson Pollocks
--Jackson's top pick this year was a 4th rounder, so really not much was expected.  But the Pollocks managed to grab a great value pick in Shane Lindblom.  He'll probably never reach the majors, but he should have a very nice minor league career and might earn a shot someday as an injury replacement thanks to his very high control.  But with the massive talent drop this year Jackson did much better by signing Dennis Ashby and Ken Puffer than taking the picks they would have gotten otherwise.
Grade: D- for the picks, A+ for nearly missing this draft entirely.

Wade Stowers
Kansas City
Express
Age: 22B/T: L/L
Born: Lincoln, AL
Position(s): P (SP1)
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Kansas City Express
--Kansas City was picking #2 this year, and was expecting big things from the pick. They ended up with SP Wade Stowers, a sure fire stud in the making with all the right ingredients for total dominance, assuming he doesn't stub his toe on the turf and start a devastating chain of injuries that could forever ruin his promising career.  Indeed, it seems as if Stowers suffered from polio or pneumonia as a youth, as his general health is quite frail and is a major red flag.  But considering the other players that could have been chosen this year, Stowers is actually the better gamble.  2nd round pick 2B Jerry Walters is a capable fielder with a capable bat.  He'll never impress, but will be a more than capable backup in the bigs.  No other top picks signed for Kansas City this season.
Grade: B (would have been an A if Stowers weren't the pitching equivalent of Wiki Vasquez)

Samuel Baker
Los Angeles
Leopards
Age: 18B/T: R/R
Born: New Berlin, IL
Position(s): SS/IF/OF/DH
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Los Angeles Leopards
--Following last seasons disaster the Leopards earned the #1 pick in the draft, and used it on a player who was clearly the best overall in the draft, SS Samuel Baker.  But as is consistent with the players in this years draft he has some problems too, which is hard to believe for a player projected near 90 overall.  His glove is elite, as are his arm strength and accuracy, but his range only projects to an 80, which means he will probably top out in the mid to upper 70s, which for a ML SS isn't the greatest.  Bakers bat is also only just above average, with good power, but only upper 60's elsewhere, which means he'll probably hit only .260 in the majors.  But he does have great health, durability, temper, and makeup, which means he should be a blast in the locker room on a daily basis.  Neither of the two other top round picks that signed for LA will ever amount to much.  LA also managed to not sign a supplemental pick this year as well, which makes this a pretty disappointing draft for the Leopards.
Grade: C+ (Baker is good, is he really worthy of the #1 pick?)

Season 15 Draft Recap - Charlotte through Florida

Jack Holt
Charlotte
Thunder
Age: 18B/T: R/R
Born: San Jose, CA
Position(s): 2B
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Charlotte Thunder
--The Thunder sure picked a bad year to have multiple compensation picks due to free agent losses.  As a result they only signed two of their six 1st and 2nd round picks.  The first signing was #13 overall, SS Jack Holt.  The Thunder wisely moved him to 2b right off, as is the theme in this draft, Holt was flawed for his projected position, having great fielding stats save for his glove, which only projects to a 70, not nearly good enough for an ML SS.  His bat is pretty nice for a SS, but only average for a 2B.  So the end result is that Charlotte got a light hitting 2B who should be great defensively at that position.  The Thunders other signed 1st round pick, CF Jose Reyes, was taken at #43 overall.  He is a fine defensive CF, and has great ability to hit lefties and is a top baserunner.  His lack of contact skills and inability to hit righties well could limit him to platoon duty in the majors however.  The rest of the Thunders draft produced some capable minor leaguers, but nobody who is truly capable of making the big leagues otherwise.  This draft has to be considered a disappointment for the Thunder considering the volume of high picks they had going in vs. the return they got coming out.
Grade: C-

Galahad Hutchinson
Columbus
HoundDogs
Age: 22B/T: L/L
Born: Tracy, CA
Position(s): LF
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Columbus HoundDogs
--The HoundDogs took a gamble by sacrificing their first round pick to sign free agent SP Tony Cho.  In hindsight that turned out to be a pretty good move, as the talent they probably could have signed at #27 overall wouldn't have been very good.  What they ended up with in the 2nd round onward was a draft that pretty much is unremarkable and average at best.  None of their picks will make the majors, although Galahad Hutchinson and Cookie Coleman do have very cool names, some of the best in the draft.  But in the ranks of draft history, this one is pretty forgettable.
Grade: D- for their picks, A+ for getting Cho instead of a chump who probably would have never made the majors

Sherm Truman
Cleveland
Steamers
Age: 19B/T: L/L
Born: Allentown, PA
Position(s): P (P)
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Cleveland Steamers
--Usually when you draft a relief pitcher who will in all likelihood top out at Setup B role on the big league team, it isn't a good thing.  But with the talent in this years draft it was actually as good as could be expected at #29 overall in the draft, and the Steamers ended up with Sherm Truman as a result.  Truman's best quality is his durability  and stamina, but his pitches in combination with a lack of velocity and tendency to give up the fly ball will probably keep Truman from ever being an effective big league pitcher.  Supplemental pick CF Juan Espinosa however is a keeper, and has a chance to be an elite defensive CF at the ML level, with a bat that is good enough to justify a spot in the lineup.  His high contact bat and elite baserunning abilities make him a legit prospect, although he is a very light hitter and will probably only manage a .270 average and .650 OPS at best in the bigs.  The rest of the Cleveland draft brought on board some very good minor leaguers, but no other big league talent.  Not a great draft at all, but certainly better than some others this year, with the Espinosa pick keeping this from being a total waste.
Grade: C-

Howard Spivey
Dover
Dingos
Age: 20B/T: R/R
Born: Jacksboro, TX
Position(s): SS/3B/2B/OF
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Dover Dingos
--With the #26 pick in the draft, the Dingos selected a top defensive SS in Howard Spivey.  Spivey also has some good contact at the plate and a decent eye, but is slow as molasses and couldn't hit a right hander if the game were slow pitch softball.  Supplemental pick Keith Sveum was good value for his location in the draft, and if his splits were a little higher would be a potential all star.  But as it is he will need to develop fully in order to just be a long reliever in the majors.  If he matures he looks to be kind of like a Zeus Stewart type of pitcher.  2nd round pick 1b J.P. Gibbons was good value for the location as well, but his bat isn't quite good enough to be a regular in the majors.  The rest of the draft for Dover featured some good minor leaguers who were good value picks, but none of them will ever see a ML roster.  Despite the flawed nature of their top two picks, this draft was par for the course this year in terms of talent.
Grade: C

Jordan Walker
Florida
Almendares
Age: 21B/T: L/L
Born: Lomira, WI
Position(s): P (ClA)
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Florida Almendares
--Florida spent a gazillion dollars on scouting this year, almost to see it go to waste thanks to a flurry of type A free agent signings.  But then they got lucky and scored a compensation pick of their own, at #60 overall in the 1st round.  They used their scouting smarts to select RP Jordan Walker, who has some of the best splits in the draft, and projected control near 100, which is as good as you can get.  He also has one of the best pitch selections in the draft.  But how did he drop to #60 then?  His extremely limited stamina and durability is the culprit.  He's limited to basically 40 innings a year tops, but they should be 40 very good innings for what it is worth.  The Almendares only signed one other top round pick, and he is only going to be good in the minors.  Despite their huge scouting investment, Florida has to be happy they didn't have to depend on it this year thanks to the very poor talent pool. 
Grade: D+ for the picks, A+ for the free agent signings that prevented them from having to draft.

Thursday, March 4, 2010

Season 15 Draft Recap - Anaheim through Chicago

Orval Edmonds
Anaheim
Sharks
Age: 19B/T: R/R
Born: New Market, AL
Position(s): SS/2B
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Anaheim Sharks
--Picking at #28 in a very weak draft meant that Anaheim didn't have much to choose from in the way of talent.  What they ended up with was Orval Edmonds, the prototypical high health/durability 2B who is average at pretty much every other category.  Edmonds will be just good enough to make an ML team eventually, but will probably just end up being a journeyman. Supplemental pick SP Lawrence Lofton has good ML potential as a long man or #5 starter thanks to his high control, and was as good as you could get at #90 overall.  3rd rounder Abraham Hill is a high end minor leaguer, as is 4th rounder Roosevelt Motte.  Considering how horrible the talent in the draft was this season, this actually isn't a bad draft.  But still, none of these guys are likely to impact the major league club in Anaheim.
Grade: C+

Brian Gang
Atlanta
Pitbulls
Age: 18B/T: L/L
Born: South Glens Falls, NY
Position(s): P (SuA)
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Atlanta Pitbulls
--As their team starts to produce winning records, the management in Atlanta is starting to discover that drafting at the end of the first round is a whole new ballgame.  What they ended up with this year was RP Brian Gang, taken at #24 overall.  Gang has very limited stamina and durability, but has great skills elsewhere across the board.  He projects to play like current ML relief pitcher Jose Rios, which means ATL should get about 40 high quality innings a year out of Gang if he matures fully.  Supplemental pick RP Ross Brownson is a tweener pitcher, best suited to long relief thanks to his mid level stamina and durabilty.  He has great pitches and control, which should offset his average splits.  He has a good future as a ML setup pitcher.  The rest of the pitchers taken in Atlanta's first five rounds will make excellent minor leaguers.
Grade: C+

Johnny Prince
Boston
Loggers
Age: 18B/T: R/R
Born: Huxley, IA
Position(s): P (SuA)
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Boston Loggers
--When can not signing the #5 overall pick be considered a success?  This year!  Thanks to the horrible talent pool, the best Boston was able to draft was above average 1B Don Elster, who rejected the Loggers initial contract offer, thus ensuring that Boston will be able to have the #5 pick in next years draft, which will hopefully have better talent.  That left them with their top pick being #48 overall RP Johnny Prince, a minor leaguer who may get a sniff of the majors should a catastrophic injury wave hit the ML squad of his franchise.   3rd rounder C Johnny Worrell is actually a viable ML talent thanks to his great bat and decent backstopping skills.  Otherwise Boston brought home some good minor leaguers, but not much else in the way of ML talent.
Grade: D for this years talent, but an A for securing a high pick next season.

Edgar Romero
Chicago
Sabercats
Age: 20B/T: L/L
Born: Scott City, KS
Position(s): CF
View Hardball Dynasty Profile

Chicago Sabercats
--Back in the good old days picking #15 meant you were going to get a stud player of the likes of Benito Rodriguez or Lyle Crudale.  But with this draft it meant signing CF Edgar Romero, who while having some very nice qualities, isn't a player of the calibur of those mentioned.  What Romero does have is an elite glove and a great batting eye, and pretty good speed.  What he lacks is the range that is necessary for a CF in larger parks, and the rest of his batting skills are only average.  But he could easily be a top tier defensive 2B for certain, and considering the talent in the draft was probably the best that was available to Chicago at his place in the draft order.  The next two picks for Chicago, RPs Wellington Mendez and Don Long, both have great control and decent pitches, but have a few flaws that might impede their progress.  The rest of Chicago's top picks were good minor leaguers who could fill in for the ML squad if it were desperate. 
Grade: C+

Thursday, January 21, 2010

Season 15 Preview - American League

Lars the Greek - Cobb Times Herald

American League


Overview: The American League has been the playground of the Cleveland Steamers for the past five seasons, as the Steamers squad has made the World Series every time during that span and won two championships, including season 14.  But if there is a weakness in the Cleveland Armor, it is their regular season play, as they have only once been the #1 seed during their run of postseason dominance.  With several teams bringing on some major talent through trades and free agency, and the continued maturation of the tough young AL West squads, the road for Cleveland looks much tougher this season.  But as Syracuse knows, and now Tacoma as well, winning a bunch of games in the regular season doesn't mean jack when you lose in a short series.  So who has made some moves to challenge?  Lars takes a look.

Projected Cy Young: Dean Hernandez - Pawtucket G-Maniacs
--Other Contenders: Kazuhiro Ong (NAS), Benito Beltre (TOR), Tommy Wakeland (VAN), Darren Howry (TAC), Eric Collins (FLA)
Projected MVP: Pedro Franco (NAS)
--Other Contenders: Lyle Crudale (CLE), Kory Arnold (ANA), Craig Lake (FLA), Vinny Jang (CLE)
Projected Fireman of the Year: Jared Jacobsen - Anaheim Sharks
--Other Contenders: Geoffrey Knight (FLA)
Projected Rookie of the Year: Thurman Tresh - Kansas City Express
--Other Contenders: Patrick Ramirez (BOS), Roosevelt Fox (KC), King Gonzalez (PAW), Hulk Boone (PAW), Sean Holt (SEA), Stan Wilkerson (TOR), Les Ingram (VAN)

Top Five Rotations in the American League

1. Pawtucket G-Maniacs
2. Toronto Blue Jays
3. Florida Almendares
4. Tacoma Jerry Gang
5. Vancouver Grizzlies

Top Five Lineups in the American League
1. Nashville Rebel Riders
2. Anaheim Sharks
3. Vancouver Grizzlies
4. Florida Almendares
5. Cleveland Steamers

Top Three Offseason Free Agent Signings
1. Craig Lake - Florida Almendares
2. Emmanuel Castillo - Nashville Rebel Riders
3. Apollo Houston - Florida Almendares

Four Teams on the Rise:
1. Kansas City Express
2. Toronto Blue Jays
3. Vancouver Grizzlies
4. Nashville Rebel Riders

Three Teams on the Decline
1. New York Expos
2. Louisville Dogs
3. Cleveland Steamers

Five prospects who could make a difference if called up this season
1. Jerome Mancuso - Cleveland Steamers
2. Mariano Ramirez - Nashville Rebel Riders
3. Russell Walker - Toronto Blue Jays
4. Enos French - Vancouver Grizzlies
5. Dan Mottola - Anaheim Sharks

Projected finishes, by division:


AL North
Pawtucket G-Maniacs - 96-66
Chicago Sabercats - 85-77
Toronto Blue Jays - 78-84
Seattle Pilots - 64-98

AL East
Dover Dingos - 94-68
Cleveland Steamers-89-73
Boston Loggers - 72-90
New York Expos - 68-94

AL South
Nashville Rebel Riders - 98-64
Florida Almendares - 97-63
Kansas City Express - 65-97
Louisville Dogs - 61-101

AL West
Tacoma Jerry Gang -100-62
Anaheim Sharks - 90-72
Vancouver Grizzlies - 90-72
Arizona Tigers - 68-94

Season 15 Preview - National League

Lars the Greek - Cobb Times Herald

There is a new tide coming in this season in the National League, and it is the new NL West rising as Omaha finally recedes after a decade of dominance.  Still strong is the entire NL East, while there are some old faces coming back for another go in the North and South.  Lars takes a look at what could potentially be a massive power shift in the upcoming seasons, and gives his predictions on things to come in the senior circuit.

National League


Overview: For years in the National League two things were a certainty; one, Syracuse would win a ton of games in the regular season and collapse in the playoffs, and two, Omaha would probably win the World Series.  But Omaha has officially put that dynasty to bed for the time being to retool what was a rapidly aging franchise.  This has blown the door wide open for the rest of the National League, and Jackson was able to capitalize last season before losing a very tightly contested World Series to the Cleveland Steamers.

This year sees some old favorites once again rising to the top, as Jackson built upon their World Series success and had some major free agent moves to bolster their lineup.  But the biggest mover and shaker this season was the Sioux Falls Corn Cleats, who had the busiest offseason in franchise history in an attempt to retake the division and recover from their worst season in team history.  The NL South is now a wide open race as well, as Syracuse was forced to shed some very talented players in order to make their budget, but they are still the match of any of the other teams in the division, just not the guaranteed lock they once were.  The West is now wide open as well, and Iowa City and San Francisco look to be running neck and neck in the race to succeed Omaha as the divisional power to be reckoned with. 

Projected Cy Young: Furio Kydd - Iowa City
--Other Contenders: Clyde Ford (SXF), Davey Silva (WIC), Ivan Canseco (SF), Junior Lee (ATL)
Projected MVP: Chipper Harper - Columbus
--Other Contenders: Paul Jung (SYR), Nick Weaver (ATL), Omar Rosado (NY2)
Projected Fireman of the Year: Kirk White - Syracuse
--Other Contenders: Sarma Inge (CLB)
Projected Rookie of the Year: Francisco Espada - Iowa City
--Other Contenders: Tim Collins (MNT), Jose Vasquez (SXF)

Top Five Rotations in the National League
1. Sioux Falls Corn Cleats
2. Atlanta Pitbulls
3. Columbus HoundDogs
4. Syracuse Beagles
5. New York Pick Pockets

Top Five Lineups in the National League
1. Columbus HoundDogs
2. New York Pick Pockets
3. Syracuse Beagles
4. Wichita Wankers
5. Jackson Pollocks

Top Three Offseason Free Agent Signings
1. Tony Cho - Columbus HoundDogs
2. Dennis Ashby - Jackson Pollocks
3. Steven Booker - Trenton Lions

Top Three Trade Acquisitions
1. Clyde Ford - Sioux Falls Corn Cleats
2. Jamie Beimel - Atlanta Pitbulls
3. Ivan Canseco - San Francisco Earthquakes

Four Teams on the Rise:
1. Iowa City Corn Dogs
2. Sioux Falls Corn Cleats
3. San Francisco Earthquakes
4. Trenton Lions

Three Teams on the Decline
1. Omaha Sluggers
2. Syracuse Beagles
3. Charlotte Thunder

Five prospects who could make a difference if called up this season
1. Theodore Hafner - Atlanta Pitbulls
2. Juan Javier - Montgomery Burns
3. Morgan Kirby - Montgomery Burns
4. Jamie Hayashi - Montgomery Burns
5. Kazuhiro Martin - San Francisco Earthquakes

Projected finishes, by division:


NL North
Sioux Falls Corn Cleats -91-71
New York Pick Pockets - 89-73
Trenton Lions - 72-90
Hartford Whalers - 70-92

NL East
Columbus HoundDogs - 94-68
Wichita Wankers - 92-70
Syracuse Beagles - 91-71
Atlanta Pitbulls - 89-73

NL South
Jackson Pollocks - 96-66
Richmond Cohibas - 87-75
Montgomery Burns - 65-97
Charlotte Thunder - 64-98

NL West
Iowa City Corn Dogs - 92-70
San Francisco Earthquakes - 88-74
Omaha Sluggers - 75-87
Los Angeles Leopards - 61-101

Saturday, January 16, 2010

Hall of Fame Preview with Lars the Greek - Pitcher Edition

Lars the Greek - Cobb Times Herald

It's time to look at the pitchers who have made their mark in Cobb World over the years, and unlike the hitters, there is a very select group of pitchers who stand head and shoulders above the rest.  First lets take a look at the HOF criteria and the pitchers that make the automatic nomination cut.

7+ All Star Appearances
  1. Kazuhiro Ong - 10
  2. Sean Hill - 9
  3. Kirk White - 9
  4. Dean Hernandez - 7
  5. Shane Parrish - 7
  6. B.C. Steenstra - 7

3+ Fireman of the Year
  1. Kirk White - 5
  2. Randall Harvey - 4
  3. Sarma Inge - 3
  4. Harold Charles - 3

3+ Cy Young Awards
  1. Dean Hernandez - 6
  2. Kazuhiro Ong - 3
  3. Phillip Brown - 3

300+ wins
--No players meet this criteria 

3000+ Ks
--No players meet this criteria

500+ SVs
  1. Sean Hill - 507

Five other great pitchers retired or nearing retirement.
  1. Vance Weaver - 179 W, 6 AS, 2 Cy Youngs, 1 Gold Glove
  2. Olmedo Contreras - 175 W, 5 AS , 1 Cy Young
  3. David Rosado - 168 W, 5 AS, 1 Cy Young
  4. Albert Franco - 181 W, 4 AS, 1 Cy Young
  5. Josias Morales - 186 W, 3 AS, 2 Gold Gloves
Lars' Top Five Picks for the Hall of Fame
--The list for the Cobb Hall of Fame obviously starts with Kazuhiro Ong and Dean Hernandez, both of whom are without a doubt the two best pitchers to ever come through the league at this point in time.  After that you would have to think that Kirk White and Sean Hill also get the nod, for their very impressive career stats and dominance of the bullpen.  The fifth slot is where it gets tricky, as there are many candidates who are deserving.
  1. Kazuhiro Ong - This spot could have easily gone to Hernandez, but Ong gets the slight nod for having greater career numbers at this point, trailing Hernandez only in Cy Youngs.  It could be debated that Ong would have had more Cy Youngs had he been in Hernandez's place, as the competition in the NL was much stiffer during his run through his peak years.  Still, both are great.
  2. Dean Hernandez - Who wouldn't want an SP who is capable of throwing 300+ innings in nearly 40 starts in a year, while winning 60% of them every season?  Hernandez is in all likelihood going to top Ongs career stats by the time he retires, and could make the 300W/3000K plateau before retirement as well, which would then catapult The Dean to #1 on Lars' list.
  3. Kirk White - In terms of pure dominance in the bullpen, there is no comparison to Kirk White.  Boasting an unbelievable combination of power, control, and an unflappable demeanor, White is the standard in Cobb as far as closers are concerned.  He doesn't have 500 saves yet, but barring injury he will certainly attain that milestone and then some, and even if he doesn't his award pedigree can't be argued with.
  4. Sean Hill - His ratings may not show it, but Hill has been the most consistently successful relief pitcher in the history of Cobb World, getting it done since season 1 and still going today.  His longevity is unmatched at the position, and his 9 All Star appearances prove that he has been an elite player for nearly all of his career.  That's Hall of Fame worthy in any argument.
  5. Phillip Brown - This spot could have easily gone to Vance Weaver, but Brown gets the nod with 3 Cy Youngs to Weavers two, and better career averages.  Brown was the elite standard for pitchers in the early years of Cobb, and had he not had part of his prime before the recorded seasons, he could have had the same career numbers as Ong and Hernandez.  Weaver may ultimately surpass him, as he has a few good years left, but at this moment it's Brown who gets the edge.

Thursday, January 14, 2010

Hall of Fame Preview with Lars the Greek

Lars the Greek - Cobb Times Herald

Normally known for his playoff and season predictions, Lars the Greek is eagerly anticipating the upcoming Hall of Fame update to HBD, and has turned his considerable prognostication prowess towards determining who is in and out of the Hall of Fame.  Using the criteria laid down from admin on high, here is the list that Lars has to work with, and predictions to follow. 

Position Players
--There have been quite a few great position players through the years in Cobb World, none greater than Jose Barrios, who owns nearly every single offensive category record and has yet to retire, and is one of the few threats in league history to top the 3,000 hit plateau.  After him though the books show a league strong in slugging hitters, with a few very dominant players, and a whole bevy of very good ones.  

Automatic Nomination Categories

7+ Silver Sluggers
  1. Jose Barrios - 8
  2. Dallas Kline - 7
10+ Gold Gloves

--No players meet this criteria

7+ All Star Appearances
  1. Jose Barrios - 10
  2. Ernie Jenkins - 9
  3. Dallas Kline - 8
  4. Vernon Jones - 8
  5. Hades Booker - 7
3+ MVPs
  1. Jose Barrios - 6
  2. Kory Arnold - 4
  3. Chipper Harper - 3
500+ Home Runs
  1. Jose Barrios - 740
  2. Kip Zeile - 665
  3. Jose Cervantes - 628
  4. Domingo Montana - 539
  5. Dallas Kline - 534
  6. Vernon Jones - 529
  7. Orber Olivo - 519
  8. Kenny Blair - 510
3000+ Hits

--No players meet this criteria

20 Players retired or near retirement who were/are great but meet none of those requirements
  1. Marino Sierra
  2. Rico Estrada
  3. Ernest McConnell
  4. Joseph Pan
  5. Thomas Hill
  6. Bob Sears
  7. Terrance Warden
  8. Rob Quinn
  9. Patrick Stanton
  10. Pat Barber
  11. Vitas Newman
  12. Fred McConnell
  13. Corey Green
  14. Ken Puffer
  15. Richard Davis
  16. Alan Peterson
  17. Mendy Strong
  18. Rico Romero
  19. Ryan Saberhagen
  20. Roosevelt Lowell
Lars Top 10 Picks for the Hall of Fame

--Obviously Jose Barrios gets the nod, as does Dallas Kline, after that the definition of greatness becomes limited to fewer categories, as only Barrios and Kline were able to achieve more than 3 of the criteria needed for automatic nomination.  Here is Lars's list:
  1. Jose Barrios - The example of greatness from day one of Cobb World, Barrios is the greatest player in the history of the league, hands down, no questions asked.  Anyone who thinks otherwise needs their head examined.
  2. Dallas Kline - For the first 10 seasons in Cobb World there was a legitimate debate as to who was greater, Kline or Barrios.  Then Kline started his decline, but his records of early Cobb dominance remain, truly an all time great.
  3. Ernie Jenkins - While he may not have reached 500 HR's, Jenkins has more all star appearances than anyone in Cobb History save Barrios, and has two MVP's, which is nothing to sneeze at.  He was an elite hitter and one of the most feared bats of his time.
  4. Marino Sierra - While Sierra didn't crack any of the criteria, he did come close with 6 All Star appearances.  What is more impressive is how complete his game was, there probably wasn't a more effective leadoff hitter in the game for the first 12 years of Cobb, and Sierra currently is a top 5 all time player in runs, stolen bases, walks, and runs created, plus he belted nearly 300 HR's with a career average around .300.  That's Hall of Fame worthy.
  5. Kip Zeile - The #2 all time home run hitter in Cobb World is a lock for the hall, and was probably the most underrated player of his era.  He did finally earn his elusive MVP, but along with Orber Olivo was shut out of the All Star game far to often, perhaps because of his shining personality.
  6. Vernon Jones - A 500 home run hitter at the catcher position is a rare thing, and Jones is the most decorated player at that position in Cobb history.  A fan favorite, Jones was also a very good defensive catcher as well as being a monster at the plate, only Patrick Stanton and Vitas Newman are close historically for catchers.
  7. Kory Arnold - Four MVP's is the most impressive stat in Arnolds career, second only to Jose Barrios' six awards.  No other player has dominated the American League like the stretch Arnold put together from seasons 8-11, although young Pedro Franco is making a run.  Arnold may possibly reach 500 home runs, but even if he doesn't he deserves a spot in the hall.
  8. Rico Estrada - Six time All Star Rico Estrada was the standard for shortstops for a decade in the first years of Cobb World.  An all time top five player in hits and runs, as well as coolness, Estrada was the first major impact international free agent to hit Cobb World, and his influence has been felt in the league ever since.
  9. Fred McConnell - McConnell gets a veteran's committee vote from Lars, as his first five seasons in the league were so completely dominating that it is hard to leave him out, imagining what he could have been if all of his prime were spent playing in recorded seasons.  A good fielder at CF as well, McConnell deserves a spot in the Hall.
  10. Jose Cervantes - Hard to imagine how a player who has hit over 600 home runs has only been an All Star twice, but Cervantes has very quietly put up some of the most ridiculous power numbers in Cobb history.  Still a very effective power hitter, it isn't unreasonable to think that he could top 700 home runs before his career is over.  That is most certainly a Hall of Fame number by any stretch of the imagination.